Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: Do that together. The gift to get to do this with the people who have agreed to come and in front of this room, share some slice of what you are revealing to them in their own work. So God, it is with gratitude that we join together this morning and pray that we would have open art, open hearts, open ears, and open minds for what you have for us today. In your name we pray. Amen.
[00:00:20] Speaker B: Amen. Thank you, Thais.
Good morning everyone. It's so good to be here with you. Thank you for your kind and generous invitation.
So there are countless ways that we could tell the story of Theology in a Time of Ecological Crisis.
To complement the two McGlory chapters, which are excellent and I'd encourage you to read them if you have the occasion to do so, I'm going to be focusing our time on two watershed moments that I think, even though they are somewhat in the past, still offer invitations for our reflection today.
And at a couple points I'm going to pause so we can have conversation and reflection in the midst of our conversation. And then I've also made sure to reserve a chunk of time for more general Q and A.
So the first. Oh, before I begin to talk about ecological crisis can bring up overwhelming emotions like anxiety, despair, guilt, confusion.
And I want to invite us that if any point today we need to take a break or step out for whatever reason, please feel free to do so.
I'm going to trust that we are all on a journey of integrating care for creation in our own lives. And I trust that the Spirit Spirit will be with each of us as we discern how we might respond to God's call.
So two watershed moments. The first is we're going to rewind to 1967. So almost 60 years ago, a controversial five page essay was published by the historian Lynn White, and it subsequently launched the fields of eco theology, environmental ethics and ecology and religion.
The wider context White is writing only five years after the publication of Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, and it's in the midst of growing public concern with pollution, pesticides and population growth.
So this essay is called the Historical Roots of the Ecologic Crisis, and White lays the burden of guilt for contemporary ecological problems at the feet of Christianity.
He says Christianity is the most anthropocentric religion the world has seen, and it has bequeathed the modern west with attitudes that have justified and accelerated the ruthless exploitation of the natural world.
So in particular, he thinks there's two beliefs, one, that humans are separate from nature, and the second that humans are the rightful masters of nature and he traces these developments to medieval Europe and, in his words, the victory of Christianity over paganism.
So White warns that we shall continue to to have a worsening ecological crisis until we reject the Christian axiom that nature has no reason for existence save to serve man.
White points to St. Francis of Assisi as advocating an alternative Christian view.
So rather than a hierarchy between humans and the rest of creation, White thinks that Francis models an alternative vision of equality of creatures.
White further argues in this essay that because the ecological crisis has religious roots, it needs a religious solution.
So here's a quote. He says, since the roots of our trouble are so largely religious, the remedy must also be essentially religious. More science and technology are not going to solve the crisis. We need to find a new religion or rethink our old one.
So let's pause for a moment.
White is focused on how Christian beliefs shape attitudes towards the natural world.
So I'd like to invite us to turn to our neighbor and think about our own histories in our own communities.
Does White's story line up with our own experiences? So think about with your neighbor, what attitudes and practices about nature and or the environment did you inherit from your formative communities? So your family, your schools, your churches think just how did you grow up thinking about the environment and if that was related to Christianity at all? So take two minutes and do some brainstorming.
So.
Take about 30 more seconds.
All right, let's start gathering back together.
So thank you for engaging with your neighbor about that question.
White's article had a strong intuitive power. A lot of people resonated with this argument, and it was so controversial that it generated this huge groundswell of scholarly response. So there's. Since its publication, there's literally been thousands of books and essays ranging from scholars of history and religion and theology and ethics that are grappling with White's challenge.
Some have tried to sort of clarify or nuance White's argument and said, well, Christianity is not as human centered as he's arguing. But many accepted White's critiques and began the work of revising, reconstructing and retrieving aspects of Christianity to make it more ecologically attuned.
So in other words, this academic work, this sort of. These fields that emerged in response to White take as a starting point Christian complicity with ecological degradation.
And they have activist aims. So this scholarly work is trying to move Christians to more faithful action with the natural world on behalf of creation.
And so we might organize these efforts in four categories.
Folks are rereading scripture, they're retrieving historical resources. They're trying to revision Christian doctrines. So how we talk about God, creation, Jesus, salvation, eschatology, et cetera, and as well as reimagining Christian liturgies and ministries of the church.
So I want to offer us, before we turn to our next watershed moment, just one characteristic example of. Of this kind of eco theology that's trying to revise Christianity in response to White's critique. So the Catholic theologian Elizabeth Johnson has a book called Ask the Beasts, and she has a chapter where she argues that Christians are inadequately concerned with creation, like White, because a belief that we as humans are set apart from the natural world. And she attributes this to traditional readings of the Genesis mandate to have dominion, which all too frequently, she says, become unrestricted domination when fueled by human greed and pride.
But Johnson argues that there's other biblical models available to imagine the human person in relationship to creation. So she has this language of a community of creatures all centered on God. So this alternative framing, she says, there's plenty of other models in the prophets, in the psalms, in the wisdom writings, which position humans not as above the living world, but situated within the living world.
So this shift from human dominion to. To a community of creatures foregrounds another whole range of values. So we could think of interdependence, reciprocity, and kinship with other creatures that can, in turn, fund ecological sensibilities.
So again, let's turn to our neighbors. That's like such a brief snapshot of this theological revision. But let's just think what shifts for you when you imagine yourself within a community of creatures. How does that feel different or what imaginative possibilities open for you when you think of being in a community of creatures?
So share with your neighbor just some reactions. What did that bring up for you.
That.
It.
Take 30 more seconds?
All right, let's gather back together.
All right, so we just talked about our first watershed moment in this story of theology in a time of ecological crisis, which is this essay by Lynn White, 1967, that says Christianity is the most anthropocentric religion that the world has known.
And we've traced one example of a theological response to White in trying to reimagine the resources of Christianity to be more ecologically attuned.
So our second watershed moment is going to be in Warren County, North Carolina. In 1982, the residents of Warren county are predominantly poor and black, four years black. Before this, the state of North Carolina selected the county for a toxic waste landfill to dispose 30,000 gallons of PCBs. PCBs were used in a wide range of industrial products. Plastics, paints, fluorescent light bulbs, copy paper.
Congress banned them in 1979 because of a growing evidence of their toxicity to humans and the environment, Especially because they accumulate in water, plants and animals. There was a famous Walter cronkite story about PCBs being found in breast milk.
So they're banned. But Warren county has picked. Excuse me, the state of North Carolina has picked Warren county for a landfill. So especially concerning for the residents of Warren county is 7ft below the site for this new landfill was the source of the community's drinking water.
So after Warren county residents failed to stop the plans with lawsuits, they turned to civil disobedience.
With help from the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, local churches organized six weeks of protests that resulted in over 500 arrests.
Drawing on the traditions of the civil rights movement, the protesters marched and sang together. They kneeled in prayer in front of police officers and they laid down on the road to stop dump trucks hauling toxic waste into their community.
This was the first time that anyone was arrested for protesting trucks hauling toxic lace dirt in Warren county is now herald as the birthplace of the environmental justice movement.
Dolly Burwell, who lived three miles from the landfill and was one of the lead organizers, later recounted. We met in that little church many nights and if it had not been for the church, I don't know what would have happened to that struggle. We sat in the church with white folks who were afraid and of course didn't know how to march or go to jail. And Reverend White said to them, there is a bright side somewhere God is going to be with you.
And so because of his spiritual guidance and leadership, we joined hands and we went to jail.
Okay, there's a tech moment. I'm going to. We're going to watch a one minute clip.
Let's see.
Isabella. I just do this. Should it work?
So there was a Duke undergraduate student named Jenny Laban who for her undergrad documentary studies class turned up at the protests. And so these are her photos and the recording is some of the protest songs.
[00:17:17] Speaker C: Turn me around I'm gonna keep keep on walking I keep on talking Marching up the freedom land Ain't going to let.
Him on Turn me around I'm going to keep on walking I keep on talking Marching after freedom.
[00:18:03] Speaker B: So I'm going to pause it on this billboard.
I don't know if it might be difficult to read. So the billboard says Hunt's Dump. Hunt was the name of the governor.
An example of one man's insensitivity to man, his God and his environment.
We pray that whenever blue the sky shall gleam and ever green the sod and man's rude work Deface no more. The paradise of God.
So we're talking about eco theology in a time.
Sorry, talk about theology in a time of ecological crisis.
So in your groups with your neighbors, how is this billboard doing theology?
In what ways are they talking about God and talking about the good life in this billboard? So see if you can try to identify any theological moves.
We're noticing where theology is emerging on this billboard.
Take a minute to brainstorm with your neighbor.
Let's hear some observations.
What are some of the ways in which this billboard is doing eco theology?
Anyone willing to share with us, feel free to just shout out an observation.
[00:20:32] Speaker D: This is a community that probably had a tradition of taking the Bible very literally.
[00:20:41] Speaker E: So that may have been a useful sign at one point. Maybe not for us to hear.
[00:20:48] Speaker B: Okay, so this community is drawing on a biblical literacy. So a commitment to scripture forming their lives.
Where do we see biblical language here?
Paradise. Paradise.
So the folks who wrote this billboard are saying that Warren county is the paradise of God. This is a profound theological claim.
This is God's place.
God delights in this place.
[00:21:20] Speaker F: I think if you substitute sin or sensitivity in that first
[00:21:24] Speaker G: line, the whole thing
[00:21:26] Speaker F: becomes a theological statement.
[00:21:28] Speaker B: Excellent. Excellent insight. And in fact, some of the protest chants explicitly say these PCBs, you know, are human sin. Right, right. So again, drawing on theological resources to interpret this. This environmental crisis in their neighborhood,
[00:21:48] Speaker H: I think there's a way that you could have, in some sense, a testament to both sin, as Carol's pointing out, and also salvation. It's all there with sin coming out in that first line, for sure. But then also the rude work of defacing. But then the sort of vision of salvation here is one that's very sort of earthy. It's right there. It's in the county. And that vision of salvation is one for the blue skies and green grass.
[00:22:21] Speaker B: Yeah, excellent, excellent. Terrific. And the last thing I'll just point out is they're praying on this billboard. So they are asking for divine intervention, which implies God is on our side. God sees us, God hears us. I heard some folks saying, like, it's almost feels like a prophetic statement, you know, even in the terms of, like, the Old Testament prophets.
So this billboard is quite representative of the theological language that came out of Warren county in the protest songs, in the prayers that you can find recorded.
So what I mainly want to emphasize here is that this billboard was not written by scholars responding to a controversial essay published in 1967 that we just talked about. Right.
Rather, it represents a community's creative and contextual response to an environmental crisis in their neighborhood. They're praying, they're singing, they're protesting. And the Warren county residents talk God as a practical strategy in response to their pressing need.
Following these protests, the United Church of Christ began a study on the link between environmental and racial justice. And in 1987 it released a landmark report called Toxic Wastes and Race in the US and it showed that race is the most predictive factor for the location of toxic waste sites.
And this report also coined the term environmental racism.
As the theologian James cone recounts, black church leaders began linking environmental issues with civil rights and economic justice.
He recalls, at one memorable gathering, they did not talk much about the ozone layer or global warming, or the endangered whale or the spotted owl. They focus primarily on the urgent concerns of their communities.
Toxic and hazardous wastes, lead poisoning, landfills and incinerators.
So we learn from the witness of Warren county that simply fixing our ideas about God and creatures alone is inadequate.
It's not enough. We must also attend to our resource intensive ways of living that, along with histories of marginalization, dispossession and racialization, poison the home places of low income communities, people of color and indigenous peoples.
Or in the words of Pope Francis, we must hear both the cry of the earth and the cry of the poor.
In preparing for my talk today, I read through the PCUSA statements on the environment.
And as you may know, these are extensive publications.
It took me a while.
As early as 1954, predecessor denominations of the PC USA called on Christians to be stewards of the earth and water. This is a direct quote. To resist their exploitation for selfish purposes and to conserve the earth for the sustenance of all living creatures through future generations.
This is a long time ago, 1954. I was also struck by the early and persistent integration of concerns for environmental justice three years before the Warren county protests in a Statement on Energy.
This statement insists the church especially should evaluate all energy choices in terms of their impact on the poor and the powerless, as well as their impact on future generations, and insist that governments observe this basic principle of justice. The needs of the poor have priority over the comfort of the rich.
Close quote.
And this emphasis continues today.
So take the statement from the 2022 General assembly on Investing in a Green Future, which has 12 pages of guidance for churches and policymakers on how to integrate the trifold work of environmental justice. Racial justice and economic justice.
Here's a quote from the document. It insists that we as the church stand in solidarity with and behind those communities that have been systematically and historically subjected to pollution and poison in their very homes, schools, workplaces and recreation spaces. Close quote.
Crises cause us to question our established ways of understanding the world and acting in the world.
So we have inherited multiple and linked crises.
A changing climate, mass extinction, pollution and toxic waste, economic and racial injustice.
Each of these crises invite us to discern anew whether our long accepted beliefs, attitudes and habits are still adequate for the situation that we find ourselves in, and whether they need revising, replacing or renouncing.
So as people who confess that Jesus is Lord, we do this discernment in the light of the gospel as we wrestle with the political, social and ecological dimensions of Christianity as a way of life.
In the encyclical Laudato Si, Pope Francis writes that the ecological crisis is a summons to profound interior conversion both for individuals and for communities.
This conversion's not a one time change of heart, but an ongoing turning towards the God who creates and sustains the world out of gratuitous love.
So I'd like to conclude our time with one final question for our consideration together before we open up for more general questions. So here's the question to talk with our neighbors.
What is our next step in this ongoing process of ecological conversion in our own lives and in our own community?
What's our next step in this process of ecological conversion in our own lives, in our community?
So take a moment to do some of that reflecting with a neighbor and then we'll draw back together.
Not.
[00:30:03] Speaker I: It.
But it was like.
[00:31:45] Speaker J: It.
[00:32:56] Speaker B: Friends, start drawing your conversation to a close.
Perhaps we could hear from two or three individuals and then we can transition to any other comments, responses, questions that you'd like to share in light of the presentation.
Anyone willing to share a next step for themselves or their community or something you learn from your neighbor?
[00:33:40] Speaker E: Very good. Excellent.
Can you give us an update on the status of Warren county today or do you know?
[00:33:50] Speaker B: I know this is.
I believe there was a settlement.
You know, I can tell you what, it's rough. The details are rough in my mind.
Excuse me. So the toxic waste dump was built despite the protests and arrests.
And then but because of the work of the the report on environmental racism and the groundswell of sort of civil engagement and organizing, there was significant changes in the electorate. So folks elected like black representatives, excuse me, following the protests and made changes in their community.
But then there was further civil Litigation that did bring settlements in the waste dump was removed.
I can't tell you most recently, though. So that was all kind of in the late 80s and 90s. I'm sorry that it's a little bit rusty in my head from the last time I taught on this. I should review that. Thank you.
The film that we watched is from the website, is called A Road to Walk, and it has all the photos from this Duke undergrad, as well as it answers your question, an update in the county and the current situation.
Thank you.
Yes.
[00:35:34] Speaker H: First of all, I'd like to make clear that I support everything that anybody is doing to make life on this planet sustainable.
[00:35:49] Speaker K: So.
But I'm a little skeptical about the argument that we can tie all of this to Christian ideas of, you know, of domination over nature.
There's a wonderful book by Elizabeth Colbert called the Sixth Extinction.
It's fabulous. You should really read it. It's a collection of essays she wrote for the New Yorker about the issue of whether or not we're in a period of extinction. There have been five before, and this one is largely caused by human beings or the existence of the human species on Earth. Let's call it that way. And there's a passage in that book where she talks that's really quite frightening, where she talks about the discovery of drawings on the walls of paintings and the development of a brain in human beings that had the capacity to reason with abstraction so that you can make a picture of an image of nature. Right.
That capacity to reason also gave us the capacity as a species to. To do tremendous destruction on every species that we have encountered. And it happens even today.
No species on Earth survives an encounter with human beings.
And we can. I mean. And that doesn't. I don't say that in the sense of there not being any hope, because we can turn those powers to alleviating that problem to some extent.
But at the same time, I'm not convinced that if Christianity never existed that we would not be in exactly the place we are in now.
Because what we're dealing with is a power that we really seem unable to teach ourselves how to control and constrain.
I think Christianity might help with that, but I don't think it's to blame for that.
[00:37:57] Speaker B: Thank you.
Thanks. So what I'm hearing is there's a way in which human dominion is descriptively true.
Right. Whether we want it or not.
So maybe the other layer that we're adding here in this conversation, even if this is descriptively true, what is our moral and theological Invitation. What kind of people and communities do we want to become in relationship to God's creation?
Yeah. Thank you. And the six extent is an excellent resource. I'm really grateful for you bringing that up. Yes, sir.
[00:38:37] Speaker L: Thank you.
I was thinking about your last question to everyone here in terms of the step, and I was sharing with my group that there is an environmental issue in the Laney Center, Delaney Hall. I'm sorry, the detention center in Newark, not too far from us, by the way, where all these immigrants are being held for months sometimes.
And there is a facility where all the carcasses from the animals that are found dead on the roads are burned there. So as soon as you approach Delaney hall, you can smell this horrible smell.
And you're visiting, you smell that only for the time that you are there. But those who are inside, they smell all the time. In addition to that, we were told when we arrived, because we want to assist those who were visiting, giving them clothes and coffee and drinks and food, et cetera, that they recommended for us to clean our shoes very well when we go back home.
Because there was a study done that they found a lot of chemicals, harmful chemicals that get stuck into the shoes. They don't want anyone to bring those chemicals to their homes.
That's because there's also right in front of Delaney hall, there is this facility where tankers are coming and get refueled, but I don't know what chemicals are there.
So on top of the chemical plant that is in front of the facility where they burn carcasses and the smoke from the trucks and the heavy traffic in front of it, that facility is exposed to horrible contamination.
And immigrants are held there for months. And, of course, staffers, too. I mean, people who work there. So this is totally inhumane circumstances based on environmental issues. So for me, it would be to push for the closing of that facility completely. I mean, it's just.
I mean, outrageous, I would say.
[00:40:49] Speaker B: Thank you.
Thank you for bringing that up as a example of where environmental injustice meets economic and racial injustice. This is an example of what folks in the environmental humanities called a sacrifice zone. So a place with concentrated toxins and human life that's deemed expendable by the larger society. Thank you. That definitely presses upon us for a next step. What is faithfulness look like for us as neighbors only an hour away?
[00:41:32] Speaker L: I
[00:41:32] Speaker I: think
[00:41:33] Speaker L: this
[00:41:33] Speaker I: terminology of sacrifice
[00:41:35] Speaker L: zone is very helpful. I'm
[00:41:36] Speaker I: from North Carolina, and
[00:41:38] Speaker L: so I know about Warren county and also the ways in which
[00:41:42] Speaker I: different counties in North Carolina are thought of as expendable.
But I'm curious. I guess what I'm thinking about is the ways in which our theology around atonement and crucifixion plays into this. So if we believe that it is okay, or it is even necessary, or even God ordained that one man be sacrificed for the good of all, are we more likely to sacrifice some communities for the quote unquote, good of all or the comfort of all?
Mark Taylor does a really good job thinking about this when it comes to the death penalty, but I also think it could apply here of, like, how even.
Yeah, just kind of extending the ways that we're thinking about our theological tools from not just how we perceive creation and the creation stories, but also even sort of the center of our faith.
Like, what does our theology around atonement have? Like, what can
[00:42:40] Speaker L: it teach
[00:42:42] Speaker I: us or even hinder
[00:42:43] Speaker L: us in
[00:42:44] Speaker I: thinking
[00:42:44] Speaker L: about. Yeah,
[00:42:45] Speaker B: thank you. That's super perceptive as a question and. And a great illustration of the work of eco theology. So how might we be needing to revise different Christian doctrines in light of ecological crisis?
I don't think I have time to ignore the capacity to fully delve into this question of sacrifice in Christian theology. It's really profound and important. And I direct you to Dr. Sarah Stewart Croker has an essay on sacrifice in environmental ethics that I would recommend as well as Ryan Juskas has an essay on sacrifice zones. Exactly this question. So they will address that really well. So I'd encourage you to look for those two pieces. But I know one move that Ryan Juskas makes is that Jesus went to the cross in Golgotha in a wasteland. So Jesus exits the city to go to die in the sacrifice zone in solidarity with the crucified peoples.
So I think that's a note, an invitation for us to consider how can we also be in solidarity with those in sacrifice zones. So thank you, Isabella.
[00:43:57] Speaker M: All
[00:43:57] Speaker A: right, last
[00:43:58] Speaker M: question.
[00:44:00] Speaker N: I believe all industrial engineering projects today require an environmental review. And it strikes me that back in Warren county, if they just applied basic common sense, they would have not put it over an aquifer of water. That's just dumb.
It's interesting that failure to apply basic common sense led to this quite dramatic,
[00:44:22] Speaker B: Right? Right. So the EPA waived their normal regulations in Warren county, and that was the basis of the lawsuits of the residents to say this is because of racism. Warren county was the.
Has the highest. Had the highest population of black residents.
And so their concern was again, they had been deemed expendable by the state of North Carolina to try to fight the siting of the waste, the landfill in their community.
It's very concerning.
[00:44:55] Speaker A: Emily, thank you so much. Can we get a round of applause for Emily?
Thank you all so much for being here this morning. Next week we have Joyce McKeegan Walker. So come on back and we'll see you next Sunday.